Side-by-side · Q2 2026 data
Five Star Bank vs Allegany First Federal Credit Union
Credit union
Allegany First Federal Credit Union
Fillmore, New York · Under $100 million in assets
Metric by metric
| Measure | Five Star Bank | Allegany First Federal Credit Union |
|---|---|---|
| TellerScore | 66 | 85 (stronger) |
| Capital cushion | 59 | 89 (stronger) |
| Loan quality | 73 (stronger) | 65 |
| Earnings | 77 | 89 (stronger) |
| Funding & liquidity | 37 | 100 (stronger) |
| Problem-loan coverage | 89 | 96 (stronger) |
| Peer percentile | 40th | 77th |
| Total assets | $6.3B | $27.1M |
| Deposits / shares | $5.3B | $23.3M |
| Capital ratio | 10.87% | 13.91% (stronger) |
| Problem loans | 0.82% (stronger) | 1.06% |
| Net charge-offs | 0.27% | 0.14% (stronger) |
| Return on assets | 1.42% | 1.73% (stronger) |
| Loans ÷ deposits | 88.7% | 31.5% (stronger) |
| Uninsured deposits | 46.4% | 0.0% (stronger) |
| Offices | 47 | 1 |
| CFPB complaints (3 yrs) | — | — |
| Complaints per $1B deposits | — | — |
| Mortgage denial rate (HMDA) | 12.7% | — |
Allegany First Federal Credit Union has the higher TellerScore (85 vs 66). On the 7 directional measures above (where higher or lower is clearly better), Five Star Bank leads on 1 and Allegany First Federal Credit Union on 6. They differ a lot in size, so ratios such as capital and liquidity are naturally different — the peer percentile shows how each compares with institutions its own size. Deposits are insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per ownership category, at both.