TellerScore

Side-by-side · Q2 2026 data

Thumb Bank and Trust vs Wildfire Credit Union

Bank

Thumb Bank and Trust

Pigeon, Michigan · $100 million – $1 billion

77of 100
Strong

Credit union

Wildfire Credit Union

Saginaw, Michigan · $1 billion – $10 billion

70of 100
Strong

Metric by metric

MeasureThumb Bank and TrustWildfire Credit Union
TellerScore77 (stronger)70
Capital cushion4460 (stronger)
Loan quality99 (stronger)80
Earnings86 (stronger)44
Funding & liquidity7892 (stronger)
Problem-loan coverage100 (stronger)93
Peer percentile68th58th
Total assets$673.3M$1.2B
Deposits / shares$595.8M$1.1B
Capital ratio9.44%10.95% (stronger)
Problem loans0.03% (stronger)0.60%
Net charge-offs0.00% (stronger)0.51%
Return on assets1.65% (stronger)0.59%
Loans ÷ deposits69.5%68.1% (stronger)
Uninsured deposits26.4%10.9% (stronger)
Offices135
CFPB complaints (3 yrs)——
Complaints per $1B deposits——
Mortgage denial rate (HMDA)18.3%12.1%

Thumb Bank and Trust has the higher TellerScore (77 vs 70). On the 7 directional measures above (where higher or lower is clearly better), Thumb Bank and Trust leads on 4 and Wildfire Credit Union on 3. Deposits are insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per ownership category, at both.

Where both have branches

Compare two institutions